A glossy finish shouldn’t come with a long ingredient list you can’t pronounce. If you’re checking labels for vegan formulas, plant-based oils, and cruelty-free production, you’re not alone. The category has grown far beyond waxy balms into hydrating oils, tinted jellies, and even kid-friendly sets. These ten picks cover everyday shine, deeper berry stains, sheer color, and playtime-friendly options, so finding the right one comes down to what your lips actually need.
Your Options, Compared
NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip Vegan Tinted Lip Gloss Bundle
Townley Girl Stitch Lip Gloss Set (10-Piece)
NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip Newsfeed (Rose Nude)
NYX Fat Oil Chillz Polar Peppermint (Sheer Blue)
NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip Missed Call (Sheer Pink)
NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip My Main (Clear)
NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip Supermodel (Shimmering Magenta)
NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip Status Update (Rich Chocolate)
NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip Follow Back (Shimmering Warm Nude)
NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip That’s Chic (Deep Berry)
The Picks, Examined More Closely
This duo lands at the top because it solves the hardest gloss problem: picking a shade without committing to one tube. You get That’s Chic, a deep berry, paired with Supermodel, a shimmering magenta, so a full workweek plus a weekend night out are both covered.
The vegan squalane base, a plant-derived moisturizer that mimics your skin’s natural oils, is the same hydrating formula found across the rest of the NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip lineup. In our view, anyone new to vegan lip products benefits most here, since you can compare two completely different finishes before buying single tubes.
Points In Its Favor
- Two shade families in one purchase, ideal for testing deeper tones and shimmers side by side
- Non-sticky texture that wears comfortably under a mask or during a long shift
- Cruelty-free branding and a vegan squalane core for hydrating wear through the day
- Universally flattering color range across the wider line, easy to swap shades later
Things To Consider
- You’re locked into two specific shades, so anyone set on a single nude or pink might prefer buying single tubes
- The glossy oil texture can transfer onto cups and collars in the first minutes after application
Feature Snapshot
Best Suited To
Shade samplers and gift shoppers who want two distinctly different gloss finishes without picking blind.
Consider Something Else When
The Townley Girl Stitch Lip Gloss Set suits a parent shopping for a child rather than an adult looking for everyday shine.
The Stitch set plays a completely different role on this list. Ten flavored tubes topped with a familiar blue alien character turn any sleepover or playdate into a small beauty moment. Formulated for kids ages three and up, this is the choice for parents who want plant-based gloss without adult shade drama.
Unlike the NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip lineup above, these are flavored novelty glosses rather than tinted oil hybrids. Flavors like cherry, bubble gum, grape, strawberry, and blueberry keep things light, and the smooth, moisturizing formula means the gloss feels more like a balm than a sticky kid-strip product.
The Upside
- Ten tubes means sharing is easy at parties, with plenty left over for solo play
- Plant-based formula keeps the ingredient list simple for cautious parents
- Beloved character packaging turns a basic gloss into a small gift or stocking stuffer
Points To Note
- Designed for ages three and up, so this isn’t the right fit if you’re shopping for your own everyday shine
- Flavored glosses tend to encourage licking, which shortens wear time and can dry out lips faster
Whose Shelf It Belongs On
Parents building a birthday gift pile or stocking a playdate activity station for young kids.
Skip It When
The NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip That’s Chic suits adults seeking a long-wear vegan gloss with deeper pigment.
Newsfeed is the quiet workhorse of the Fat Oil Lip Drip range. A rose nude tint reads as “polished but not made-up”, which is exactly what most people want on a Tuesday morning. The vegan squalane keeps lips cushioned through long meetings.
Compared to the bundle above, this is the single-shade alternative for anyone who already knows their undertone. You may find the shine level slightly higher than a traditional gloss, so a light dab is plenty for low-key daytime wear.
What Makes Sense
- Rose nude undertone flatters a wide range of skin tones for everyday office wear
- Vegan squalane base cushions lips for up to 12 hours, cutting down on midday touch-ups
- Non-sticky oil texture wears comfortably under face masks and scarves
- Plays well layered over lip liner or worn solo for a barely-there tint
Worth Noting
- The soft tint can look almost clear on deeper skin tones, so swatching first is worth it
- The doe-foot applicator carries more product than expected, so a careful wipe helps avoid over-applying
Made For
Office workers and minimal-makeup routines that still want a hydrated, pulled-together finish.
Not Your Match When
The NYX Fat Oil Chillz Polar Peppermint suits anyone wanting a cooler, sheer-blue tinted gloss with a sensory twist.
Polar Peppermint is the weirdo of the list, in the best sense. A sheer blue jelly tint with a cooling sensation makes this the gloss you’ll reach for on hot days or when you want something that feels like a treat on the lips.
The vegan formula pairs cloudberry oil, raspberry oil, and squalane for a cushiony wear. Unlike the rose-tinted options above, the color payoff here is minimal, so the appeal is texture and sensation as much as shade.
A Few Strong Suits
- Cooling peppermint sensation wakes up tired lips in summer heat
- Cloudberry and raspberry oils add antioxidant-rich moisture alongside squalane
- Sheer blue tint creates a subtle, gloss-only look without competing with eye makeup
- Comfortable jelly texture avoids the tacky feel of older-generation glosses
Trade Offs
- The blue tint is more novelty than everyday, so pairing it with warm-toned looks takes practice
- The cooling effect can tingle on freshly exfoliated or chapped lips
Quick Facts
Who It Suits Best
Heat-weather gloss lovers and anyone curious about jelly-texture tints with a sensory twist.
Look Elsewhere When
The NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip Missed Call fits anyone wanting a more traditional sheer pink wash without the cooling sensation.
Missed Call delivers a whisper of pink that mimics a just-kissed flush. For shoppers who want a vegan gloss that doesn’t read as “wearing gloss,” this is the closest the lineup gets to a tinted-balm effect with actual shine.
The squalane hydration matches the rest of the Fat Oil Lip Drip family. In most makeup routines, the sheer pink acts as a step up from clear gloss without the commitment of a true pigment.
The Good Stuff
- Sheer pink pigment creates a believable “your lips but better” wash
- Layered friendly: looks great alone or over a matching lip liner
- Hydrating squalane keeps lips soft without the waxy drag of a traditional balm
Minor Gripes
- Light pigment won’t show up much in low natural light, so the effect reads mostly as shine
- The slim tube can roll off a vanity without a flat surface to rest on
Perfect Match For
Soft-glam routines and minimalist makeup drawers where a single sheer pink earns the most use.
Reach For A Different Pick When
The NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip Status Update is a better match for anyone wanting a richer chocolate stain with the same hydrating base.
My Main is the unsung hero of the lineup: a clear vegan gloss that adds shine, moisture, and slip without changing whatever lip color you’ve already applied. Think of it as a finishing coat rather than a stand-alone product.
Compared to Missed Call, this shade skips pigment entirely. For lipstick collectors who rotate colors but want one hydrating gloss to seal them all, the clear formula earns its place on the vanity.
Everyday Advantages
- Universal clear finish layers over any lipstick without dulling the color
- Hydrating squalane makes it double as a nighttime lip treatment
- Non-sticky oil texture keeps hair from sticking to lips on windy days
Room For Improvement
- No tint means this gloss won’t help on days you skip lipstick entirely
- Wears off mid-shift, so reapplying every few hours becomes part of the routine
The Right Fit
Lipstick layering fans who want one universal topper across their whole color rotation.
Where Another Pick Suits Better
The NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip Follow Back suits shoppers who want a hint of warm nude shimmer in a single tube.
Supermodel leans into the shimmer side of the Fat Oil Lip Drip range. The magenta base reads playful rather than subtle, so this is the gloss that earns its place at dinners, photo shoots, and anywhere your lip color is the focal point.
Compared to That’s Chic, the magenta gives cooler undertones. In our view, anyone building a small collection benefits from owning this shade for special occasions while keeping a nude or clear option for daily wear.
What Works In Its Favor
- Shimmering magenta pigment pops in low evening light
- Hydrating squalane keeps a bold shade from drying out lips mid-event
- Buildable coverage lets you dial from a soft wash to full magenta intensity
Honest Caveats
- The cool magenta undertone can clash with warm blush choices, so color pairing takes thought
- Shimmer particles tend to settle into fine lip lines as the gloss fades
Who Will Love This
Evening-event regulars and shimmer fans who want bold color with hydrating comfort.
Swap It Out When
The NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip Newsfeed works better for daytime office settings where a softer rose nude reads as more polished.
Status Update is the deepest warm-brown option in the Fat Oil Lip Drip lineup. For anyone drawn to monochrome looks or ’90s-inspired brown lips, this delivers pigment without sacrificing the hydrating finish the range is known for.
The richer pigment behaves differently from the sheer pink washes earlier in the list. Depending on how heavily you apply, you can swing from a tinted-moisturizer lip to a full brown stain in a single tube.
Where It Delivers
- Deep chocolate pigment gives a bold, statement lip without a separate lipstick step
- Vegan squalane keeps a heavier pigment from feeling drying or chalky
- Layering over a brown lip liner extends wear through dinner and drinks
Possible Compromises
- Deep pigment transfers more visibly onto cups and cloth masks than sheer shades
- The brown undertone can read muddy on cooler skin tones without careful matching
Feature Rundown
Built With In Mind
Statement-lip enthusiasts and anyone rebuilding a brown-toned makeup wardrobe around vegan formulas.
Where A Sibling Pick Shines
The NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip Missed Call fits shoppers wanting a softer everyday pink without the bold pigment commitment.
Follow Back sits in the sweet spot between the sheer pink of Missed Call and the bold magenta of Supermodel. A warm nude with light shimmer works across both day and evening looks, which is why this shade quietly becomes the most-used tube in a collection.
Versatility is the main draw. You may find this is the gloss that survives a morning meeting, an afternoon coffee, and an evening dinner without needing to swap products.
Practical Advantages
- Warm nude tone flatters a wide range of skin tones with minimal swatching
- Subtle shimmer adds evening dimension without competing with eye makeup
- Hydrating vegan formula keeps lips cushioned across long, varied days
A Few Limitations
- The warm undertone can read slightly orange on cool-toned complexions
- Shimmer tends to migrate into fine lip lines after several hours of wear
Who Should Grab It
Anyone wanting one versatile tube that transitions between day and night without an extra product change.
A Better Fit Elsewhere
The NYX Fat Oil Chillz Polar Peppermint is the right pick when you want a novelty tint with a cooling twist over a traditional shimmer.
That’s Chic rounds out the list with a deep berry that earns its strongest reviews in fall and winter. The pigment is rich enough to replace a lipstick, while the vegan oil base keeps the comfort level of a balm.
Compared to Status Update, this berry skews cooler and brighter. If your wardrobe leans jewel tones, this is the single-shade alternative to the bundle at the top of the list.
A Few Highlights
- Deep berry pigment flatters cooler skin tones beautifully
- Vegan squalane base softens a typically drying bold pigment
- Buildable coverage goes from a sheer berry wash to a full wine-stained lip
Potential Drawbacks
- The deep berry can settle into fine lip lines without exfoliating first
- Cooler undertones may wash out very warm skin tones without a balancing blush
At A Glance
Built With In Mind
Cooler skin tones and anyone leaning into jewel-tone wardrobes during the colder months.
Not Your Match When
The NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip Follow Back is a better fit for warmer complexions wanting a versatile nude shimmer year-round.
Picking Vegan Lip Glosses That Actually Work for You
The “vegan” label covers a wider range than most shoppers expect. Some formulas skip animal-derived ingredients like beeswax, lanolin, and carmine (a red pigment made from crushed beetles), while others add plant oils like squalane, cloudberry, or raspberry seed for hydration. A vegan gloss can still contain synthetic fragrance or preservatives, so checking the ingredient list matters even after you see the label on the box.
Finish matters as much as ingredients. High-shine, oil-based formulas like the Fat Oil Lip Drip line behave more like a treatment than a traditional sticky gloss. Older-style glosses coat the lips with film-forming polymers, which is why they feel tacky. Modern oil formulas wear more like a serum, but they transfer more easily onto cups. Choosing between the two comes down to whether comfort or transfer-resistance matters more on a busy day.
Pigment level is the next filter. Sheer washes (Missed Call, Newsfeed) layer easily over liner or lipstick. Mid-range shimmers (Follow Back, Supermodel) read as a true gloss. Deep stains (Status Update, That’s Chic) work as a lipstick replacement. Most collections benefit from at least one tube from each tier so any makeup look has a matching gloss already in the drawer.
Wear scenarios shape the final call. Commuters benefit from non-sticky formulas that survive masks and scarves. Event-goers want a richer pigment that photographs well. Parents shopping for kids need age-appropriate, often flavored options like the Stitch set. Matching the gloss to the moment prevents the common complaint of owning five tubes and reaching for the same one every day.
Key Considerations Across These Picks
Mistakes Worth Dodging
Plenty of shoppers grab a vegan gloss for the label without reading the actual ingredient list. Some “vegan” formulas still include synthetic fragrance or allergens that matter to sensitive lips. Check for the specific plant oils named on the label, not just the vegan certification.
A second slip-up is matching shade to skin tone by the swatch on a hand. Lips have different undertones than the back of your hand, so a berry that looks deep on your palm may pull much brighter on your lips. Whenever possible, look for swatches on actual lips or check return policies before committing.
Where The Extra Money Goes
Higher-tier vegan glosses invest in their oil complexes, layering squalane with cloudberry, raspberry, or other plant oils that add antioxidant benefits. The basic end of the category relies on a single hydrating agent, which works fine but lacks the multi-oil richness.
Premium formulas also tend to use better pigment suspension, meaning deeper shades stay even instead of pooling at the edges. For everyday sheer shades, the upgrade is subtle. For bold berry and chocolate tones, the pigment quality becomes more visible after a few hours of wear.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes a lip gloss vegan? A vegan lip gloss skips all animal-derived ingredients, including beeswax, lanolin, and carmine, and uses plant-based or synthetic alternatives instead.
Are vegan lip glosses less hydrating than regular ones? Not necessarily. Many vegan glosses, including the NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip range, use squalane and plant oils that match or exceed the hydration of traditional formulas.
Can kids use vegan lip glosses safely? Age-specific formulas like the Townley Girl Stitch set are designed for kids ages three and up, with milder ingredients and playful flavors suited to younger users.
Do vegan glosses wear as long as regular ones? Wear time depends more on the oil or polymer base than on the vegan label. Oil-based vegan glosses feel comfortable but transfer more, while film-forming glosses last longer but can feel tacky.
How do I pick the right shade for my skin tone? Cooler berry and magenta shades flatter cool undertones, while warm nudes and chocolates work better on warm skin. Testing a sheer wash first helps confirm undertone before committing to a deeper pigment.
Closing Remarks
The right vegan lip gloss comes down to what your lips actually need day to day: hydration, pigment, flavor, or novelty. Start with one sheer shade to test the formula, then add a deeper berry or shimmer for variety. If you’re shopping for a child, keep age-appropriate sets like the Stitch bundle in a separate category from your own collection.
